Knowledgebase

Fix DNS Related SSL Handshake Failures

In today's digital landscape, ensuring secure communication between clients and servers is more important than ever. Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) or its successor, Transport Layer Security (TLS), enables encrypted communication, ensuring that sensitive information such as passwords, payment details, and personal data are safely transmitted over the internet.

However, SSL/TLS handshakes may sometimes fail due to DNS-related issues, causing disruptions in secure communication. These failures can prevent users from accessing a website or application securely and often lead to frustrating experiences. DNS-related SSL handshake failures can occur for a variety of reasons, from incorrect DNS configurations to issues with DNS resolution and propagation.

This guide aims to provide a thorough understanding of DNS-related SSL handshake failures, including the causes, troubleshooting steps, and solutions for resolving these issues.

Understanding SSL Handshake

An SSL handshake is the process by which a secure connection is established between a client (e.g., a browser) and a server. During the handshake, several things happen:

  1. Server Authentication: The server sends its SSL certificate to the client.
  2. Session Key Exchange: The client and server agree on a shared encryption key for the session.
  3. Data Encryption: The connection is established, and both parties begin securely exchanging data.

If any part of this process fails, it can result in an SSL handshake error, often due to misconfigurations in the server or DNS settings.

What Are DNS-Related SSL Handshake Failures?

When DNS issues affect the SSL handshake process, it typically happens during the server's attempt to authenticate its identity or while establishing a secure channel. These errors can happen due to incorrect DNS records, expired certificates, or issues with the server that prevent the proper resolution of SSL certificates.

Here are some common DNS-related causes for SSL handshake failures:

  1. DNS Misconfiguration: If your DNS records point to the wrong IP address or an outdated server, SSL certificates won’t match the domain, causing SSL handshake failures.
  2. DNS Propagation Delays: If DNS changes haven’t propagated properly across the network, clients may be directed to old servers that don’t support valid SSL certificates.
  3. Missing or Incorrect CNAME Records: If you are using subdomains, the correct CNAME records must be in place to point to the main domain, which has the correct SSL certificate.
  4. DNS Cache Issues: DNS servers cache records to speed up domain resolution. If a cached DNS record is incorrect or outdated, it may cause SSL handshake failures.
  5. DNSSEC (DNS Security Extensions) Issues: DNSSEC is a protocol that adds an extra layer of security to DNS queries. If DNSSEC is misconfigured, it may prevent proper SSL certificate validation.

Common DNS-Related SSL Handshake Failure Scenarios

Incorrect DNS Records

If the DNS records do not correctly point to the server hosting the SSL certificate, clients may attempt to connect to a different server. This mismatch causes the SSL certificate to be invalid for that domain.

Example:

  • Your website uses an SSL certificate for www.example.com, but DNS records point to a different IP address or server that does not have the same certificate. When a browser tries to establish a secure connection, it finds that the certificate does not match, leading to a handshake failure.

DNS Propagation Delays

When DNS records are updated, such as after migrating servers or changing IP addresses, it may take time for the changes to propagate across the global DNS network. During this propagation period, some users may still connect to the old server with invalid or expired certificates.

Example:

  • After migrating your website to a new server, DNS changes can take up to 48 hours to propagate. During this time, some users may encounter SSL handshake failures because they are directed to the old server with an expired or mismatched SSL certificate.

Missing or Incorrect CNAME Records

If your website uses a subdomain (e.g., shop.example.com) with a different server but lacks the proper CNAME record pointing to the primary domain, clients may not resolve the correct SSL certificate.

Example:

  • If shop.example.com does not have a proper CNAME record pointing to example.com, users may experience SSL handshake errors when attempting to access the subdomain.

DNS Cache Issues

DNS servers cache DNS records to improve resolution speed. If there is a change in the DNS settings, cached records can lead to incorrect routing or SSL certificate mismatches.

Example:

  • After updating your DNS records to point to a new server, the DNS cache might still direct some users to the old server, causing SSL handshake errors if the old server has a different certificate.

DNSSEC Issues

DNSSEC is a security feature that ensures the authenticity of DNS records by using cryptographic signatures. If DNSSEC is not correctly configured or is mismatched, it may prevent proper SSL certificate validation, causing handshake failures.

Example:

  • If your DNSSEC records are incorrect or the domain is not properly signed, clients may not trust the SSL certificate, leading to handshake failures.

How to Troubleshoot DNS-Related SSL Handshake Failures

Check DNS Records

The first step in troubleshooting DNS-related SSL handshake failures is to check your DNS records to ensure they are correctly pointing to the right server.

  • Verify A Records: Ensure that your domain’s A records point to the correct IP address of the server hosting your website with the valid SSL certificate.
  • Check CNAME Records: If you’re using subdomains, verify that the CNAME records are properly set up to point to the primary domain.
  • Validate MX and TXT Records: If you're setting up SSL for email, verify that MX (Mail Exchange) and TXT records are correctly configured for email verification (e.g., for SPF or DKIM).

Check SSL Certificate Installation

Ensure that your SSL certificate is correctly installed on the server. The SSL certificate should match the domain name and be issued by a trusted Certificate Authority (CA).

  • Verify the Certificate: Use an online SSL checker (e.g., SSL Labs' SSL Test) to verify that the SSL certificate is properly installed and matches the domain.
  • Check the Certificate Expiration: Ensure that the SSL certificate has not expired. If it has, renew the certificate with your CA.
  • Ensure Intermediate Certificates: Sometimes, SSL certificates require intermediate certificates to be installed for proper validation. Ensure that all necessary intermediate certificates are present on your server.

Check DNS Propagation

When you make changes to DNS records, it may take up to 48 hours for the changes to propagate across all DNS servers globally. During this time, some users may experience issues with SSL handshake due to outdated DNS records.

  • Use a DNS Propagation Checker: Tools like WhatsMyDNS or DNS Checker can show you the global propagation status of your DNS records.
  • Be Patient: If you have recently updated DNS records, wait for the changes to propagate before troubleshooting further.

Clear DNS Cache

Outdated or incorrect cached DNS records can cause SSL handshake failures. Both your local machine and DNS servers can cache DNS records.

  • Clear Local DNS Cache: On your local machine, clear the DNS cache to ensure that you are using the most up-to-date DNS records. This can be done by running the following command:
    • On Windows: ipconfig /flushdns
    • On macOS: sudo killall -HUP mDNSResponder
  • Clear DNS Cache on DNS Server: If you're managing your own DNS server, clear its cache to ensure that it resolves the latest DNS records.

Check DNSSEC Configuration

If you’re using DNSSEC, verify that your DNSSEC settings are correctly configured.

  • Verify DNSSEC Records: Use tools like DNSViz or Verisign’s DNSSEC Debugger to check that your DNSSEC records are correctly signed and match the SSL certificate.

Test the SSL Handshake

Once DNS settings are confirmed, use online tools or command-line utilities to test the SSL handshake directly.

  • SSL Labs SSL Test: This tool provides a comprehensive report on your SSL configuration, including DNS resolution and handshake issues.
  • Command Line (OpenSSL): You can manually test the SSL handshake using OpenSSL commands:
    bash
     
    openssl s_client -connect example.com:443
    This command will provide details about the SSL handshake process and indicate if there are any issues.

Preventing Future DNS-Related SSL Handshake Failures

While troubleshooting will help resolve existing issues, there are several strategies you can implement to prevent future DNS-related SSL handshake failures:

Monitor DNS Records Regularly

Regularly monitor your DNS records to ensure that they are up to date. Use automated tools to check for DNS configuration changes and SSL certificate validity. This proactive approach helps to catch issues before they affect users.

Use a Reliable DNS Provider

Choose a reliable DNS provider that offers high availability, low latency, and excellent support. A good DNS provider will also provide DNS monitoring and alerting features.

Implement DNSSEC Properly

Ensure that DNSSEC is correctly configured for your domain to prevent potential security risks. Regularly audit your DNSSEC settings to avoid misconfigurations that can impact SSL validation.

Use Content Delivery Networks (CDNs)

By using a CDN, you can offload SSL/TLS termination to the CDN provider, which can provide extra protection against DNS issues and improve performance by serving content closer to users.

Minimize DNS Propagation Time

When making changes to your DNS configuration, lower the TTL value temporarily to speed up DNS propagation. Once the changes are fully propagated, you can revert the TTL to a higher value for caching purposes.

 

Usage Field: Fix DNS-Related SSL Handshake Failures

Purpose:
This field is focused on resolving issues where DNS misconfigurations or failures lead to SSL handshake errors. DNS and SSL/TLS are fundamental to secure online communications, and problems in either system can disrupt access to websites or services. These failures typically arise when DNS records are incorrect, outdated, or not properly resolving to the correct server with the appropriate SSL certificate.

Use Cases:

  1. Website Security: Ensuring a secure connection to a website via HTTPS by solving SSL handshake failures related to DNS issues.
  2. E-Commerce Platforms: Fixing SSL handshake failures for secure transactions on e-commerce sites caused by DNS misconfiguration.
  3. Enterprise Network Services: Resolving DNS-related SSL issues for internal network services, APIs, or applications.
  4. Email Server Configuration: Fixing SSL handshake errors related to misconfigured DNS records for email servers (SMTP, IMAP, POP).
  5. SSL Certificate Validation: Troubleshooting SSL issues where DNS configurations prevent proper certificate validation or domain matching.

Technical Issue: Fix DNS-Related SSL Handshake Failures

Incorrect DNS Records Pointing to an Outdated Server

  • Issue: DNS records point to an old server or one that doesn't host the current SSL certificate.
  • Cause: When DNS settings haven’t been updated after a server migration, clients are directed to a server without the proper SSL certificate.
  • Solution: Verify and update DNS records (A, CNAME) to ensure they point to the correct server that holds the valid SSL certificate.

DNS Propagation Delays

  • Issue: DNS changes take time to propagate, causing inconsistent server resolution.
  • Cause: After DNS changes, some users may still be directed to the previous server with an expired or mismatched SSL certificate.
  • Solution: Use DNS propagation tools (e.g., WhatsMyDNS) to check the propagation status. Be patient, as propagation can take up to 48 hours.

Mismatched Domain Name and SSL Certificate

  • Issue: SSL certificates are issued for specific domain names, and DNS resolution needs to match the certificate.
  • Cause: The DNS is resolving to a different server or a subdomain not included in the certificate’s Subject Alternative Name (SAN).
  • Solution: Ensure the SSL certificate matches the domain, and that the correct subdomains are included in the certificate. Verify DNS settings for accuracy.

Missing or Incorrect CNAME Records

  • Issue: CNAME records are improperly configured for subdomains, resulting in an SSL mismatch.
  • Cause: If subdomains are used (e.g., shop.example.com), the CNAME may not point to the correct domain, leading to SSL validation errors.
  • Solution: Check CNAME records for subdomains and ensure they are correctly pointing to the main domain that holds the SSL certificate.

DNS Cache Issues

  • Issue: Old or incorrect DNS records are cached by local DNS resolvers or clients.
  • Cause: Outdated DNS records in caches can cause incorrect resolution, leading to SSL certificate errors.
  • Solution: Clear the DNS cache on your local machine or DNS server to ensure updated records are being used.

 Misconfigured DNSSEC

  • Issue: DNSSEC prevents DNS resolution when incorrectly configured, affecting SSL validation.
  • Cause: DNSSEC misconfigurations or signature mismatches can prevent the client from trusting the DNS resolution, thus failing the SSL handshake.
  • Solution: Check DNSSEC records for correct signing and alignment with your DNS configuration using tools like DNSViz or Verisign DNSSEC Validator.

Expired SSL Certificate

  • Issue: An expired SSL certificate can cause handshake failures, especially when DNS resolves to a server still using the old certificate.
  • Cause: If the DNS resolves to a server with an expired SSL certificate, browsers will reject the connection.
  • Solution: Ensure SSL certificates are up to date and renewed before expiration.

Server Configuration Issues

  • Issue: The server hosting the SSL certificate may be misconfigured, causing SSL handshakes to fail despite correct DNS settings.
  • Cause: Issues such as missing intermediate certificates, outdated protocols (e.g., SSL instead of TLS), or server misconfigurations can cause failures.
  • Solution: Check server SSL configuration, including intermediate certificates, SSL/TLS versions, and cipher suites.

DNS Resolver Problems

  • Issue: DNS resolvers may fail to resolve domain names properly due to issues with DNS servers or misconfigured DNS settings.
  • Cause: Local DNS resolvers may not correctly forward requests to authoritative nameservers or may be blocked by firewall rules.
  • Solution: Test with different DNS servers (e.g., Google’s 8.8.8.8 or Cloudflare’s 1.1.1.1) to confirm resolution issues.

Firewall or Network Restrictions

  • Issue: Network-level restrictions can block DNS requests or SSL handshakes, causing failures.
  • Cause: Firewalls, network filters, or DNS over HTTPS (DoH) restrictions can interfere with DNS resolution and SSL validation.
  • Solution: Check firewall settings to ensure that DNS traffic (port 53) and SSL/TLS connections (ports 443, 993, etc.) are allowed.

Technical FAQ for Fixing DNS-Related SSL Handshake Failures

What is an SSL handshake and how does DNS affect it?

  • Answer: An SSL handshake is a process where a client and server negotiate encryption protocols, verify each other’s certificates, and establish a secure connection. DNS affects the handshake by resolving the domain name to an IP address. If DNS resolves to the wrong server or a server without the appropriate certificate, the SSL handshake will fail.

Why does DNS propagation delay affect SSL handshakes?

  • Answer: When DNS changes are made, it can take time for those changes to propagate across the internet. During this propagation period, some users may still connect to an old server with an invalid or expired SSL certificate, leading to SSL handshake failures.

How can I verify if my DNS records are correct for SSL?

  • Answer: Use DNS lookup tools such as dig or nslookup to verify that your domain’s A and CNAME records point to the correct server. You can also use online DNS checkers like WhatsMyDNS to verify DNS records globally.

How do I clear the DNS cache to resolve SSL issues?

  • Answer: To clear the DNS cache:
    • On Windows: Open Command Prompt and type ipconfig /flushdns.
    • On macOS: Use the command sudo killall -HUP mDNSResponder.
    • On Linux: Use sudo systemctl restart systemd-resolved (or similar commands based on the distribution).

What is DNSSEC and how can it affect SSL?

  • Answer: DNSSEC (Domain Name System Security Extensions) adds a layer of security to DNS by preventing DNS spoofing and cache poisoning. However, if DNSSEC is misconfigured, it can prevent proper DNS resolution, which in turn can affect SSL validation and cause handshake failures.

Can a mismatched DNS record cause SSL certificate errors?

  • Answer: Yes, if DNS records (such as A or CNAME records) point to a server that does not have the correct SSL certificate or if the certificate doesn’t match the domain, SSL handshake failures will occur. The server and domain must match for the handshake to succeed.

How do I know if my SSL certificate has expired?

  • Answer: You can use tools like SSL Labs’ SSL Test to check if your SSL certificate is expired. Alternatively, you can manually inspect the certificate in your browser or use command-line tools like openssl s_client to view certificate expiration details.

What tools can help diagnose SSL handshake failures?

  • Answer: You can use several diagnostic tools, such as:
    • SSL Labs’ SSL Test: Provides a detailed analysis of SSL configurations, including DNS and certificate information.
    • OpenSSL: Use the openssl s_client command to test the SSL handshake from the command line.
    • DNS Propagation Tools: Services like WhatsMyDNS show how DNS changes propagate globally.

How do I test DNS resolution without affecting my live website?

  • Answer: Use a staging domain or test subdomain to verify DNS and SSL configurations. You can also use DNS lookup tools without making changes to live settings or modify the local host file temporarily to test DNS resolution for a specific domain.

What should I do if DNS and SSL configurations seem correct but issues persist?

  • Answer: If configurations appear correct, check for network or firewall restrictions that may be blocking DNS requests or SSL connections. Additionally, confirm that your DNS resolver is working correctly, or try switching to a different DNS service (e.g., Google’s 8.8.8.8 or Cloudflare’s 1.1.1.1) for testing.
  • 0 Users Found This Useful
Was this answer helpful?

Related Articles

DNS-Based Content Filtering for Businesses

In today’s digital world, businesses rely heavily on internet connectivity to perform everyday operations. However, unrestricted access to the internet poses significant risks, including exposure...

Overcome DNS Conflicts with ISP Settings

The Domain Name System (DNS) is a critical component of the internet infrastructure, responsible for converting human-readable domain names (like www.example.com) into machine-readable IP addresses...

Professional Domain Redirection Setup via DNS

In today's digital age, domain redirection is a fundamental practice for managing web traffic. Whether you are consolidating multiple domain names, changing your website's URL, or ensuring proper...

DNS Query Performance Enhancement Services

The Domain Name System (DNS) is an integral part of the internet infrastructure. It acts as the phonebook of the web, converting human-readable domain names like www.example.com into...

Set Up Dynamic DNS for Remote Access Solutions

In an increasingly connected world, remote access solutions have become essential for businesses and individuals who require secure and flexible access to their network resources from any location....